Saturday, July 17, 2021

"It is not just any civilization that" hands the riches of others on down intact

"It is unheard of in the history of religions that the holy book of a religion contain, at its side, that of an earlier religion.  Moreover, the second book, the New Testament, constitutes something like a commentary on the first.  More exactly, using the technical term of Jewish exegesis, the New Testament is like a pesher of the Old, which is to say an interpretation that applies the text to the present situation and interprets it in function of a key event, here the Passion and Resurrection of Jesus."

     Rémi Brague, "Inclusion and digestion:  two models of cultural appropriation in response to a question of Hans-Georg Gadamer (Tübingen, September 3, 1996)," in Rémi Brague, The legend of the Middle Ages:  philosophical explorations of medieval Christianity, Judaism, and Islam, trans. Lydia G. Cochrane (Chicago and London:  The University of Chicago Press, 2009), 155 (145-158).
     According to Brague, digestion (to the point of destruction) is the approach characteristic of Islam, and inclusion, that of Christianity.  If I understand him correctly, the latter is viewed as a strength at the beginning of the essay ("It is not just any civilization that encourages a style of appropriation that permits the transmission of an object of that appropriation to future generations so that they can newly appropriate it themselves" (145)), but a weakness at the end ("European culture suffers from dispepsia", which is to say indigestion; for the European "stomach—precisely because of all the undissolved inclusions within it—has become more like a gizzard. . . . thanks to the model of appropriation that Europe developed with its sources, it can appropriate other cultures without feeling obliged to digest them" (158)).

No comments: