Tuesday, July 1, 2025

"a deficiency inherent to the Latin races"

"The condition of Mexico, little satisfactory as it may appear, when compared to our own Republic, is greatly improved from what it was a few years ago; and there is no man living to whom the country is as much indebted as to Juarez for that improved state of affairs.  We Americans generally, in our estimate of that country and its people, commit the error of judging them from our own standpoint, making ourselves the standard, without duly taking into account the disadvantages and drawbacks under which they are laboring.  We are a people among whom republicanism is more fully understood than almost anywhere else in the world.  It almost seems instinctive with us; hence the respect for the Constitution and laws enacted by the majority of the sovereign people.   This respect for the laws is one of our distinctive features, and is in fact the chief guarantee for the duration of the republic:  but we cannot wonder to find the Mexicans as inferior to us in this point as in many others.  Their comparatively low state of civilization, the demoralizing influence of long continued Spanish tyranny, and perhaps a deficiency inherent to the Latin races, have been as many drawbacks to the full comprehension of the principles of republicanism.  In most of the South American republics we notice the same condition."

     [Frederick Douglass], "Our southern sister republic," The new national era, ed. Frederick Douglass, vol. 2, no. 31 (Thursday, August 10, 1871), p. 2, col. 3.  I was put onto this by (and am "quoting" very selectively “from”) Adam Hochschild, “One brief shining moment,” The New York review of books 72, no. 9 (May 29, 2025), 42 (41-42).

Monday, June 30, 2025

Martin Luther on the deserving and undeserving poor

      "In the second place, this '[Give to] everyone' [(Mt 5:42)] does not mean someone who has or can have enough.  There are, especially in our age, a great number of wicked scoundrels who pretend to be poor, needy beggars and deceive people; they ought to receive their 'alms' with a rope and sack from Master Hans—if only the authorities were not so lax and negligent and did not let the gallows stand idle on the streets as if on holiday.  Similarly, there are a good many loafers these days who, being active, healthy, and strong, might well work, serve, and make a living.  But they rely on Christians and pious people being glad to give.  And where there is not enough giving or people do not give adequate amounts, they supplement it by stealing—indeed, by taking things openly in yards, on the street, and even in houses.  The end of it is that I am in doubt whether there was ever such a time when stealing and taking was so common, and yet all the gallows stood all empty and, as it were, on holiday all the year round.  Here Christ commanded you to give not to these kinds of people but only to the needy in your city or around you, as Moses teaches, who are unable to work, serve, or make a living, or else do not make enough money despite their constant labor and service.  In these cases one is to give aid, gifts, and loans whether it is a friend or an enemy.  A Christian can certainly do this and will not find it too difficult, especially when those in charge restrain foreign beggars and vagabonds or strangers and loafers."

      Martin Luther, "To pastors, that they should preach against usury" (1539), trans. Matthew Carver, LW 61, Theological and polemical works, ed. Benjamin Mayes (2021), pp. 308-309.  =WA 51, pp. 383 l. 17-384 l. 3.  I was put onto this by Eberhard Jüngel, “Gewinn im Himmel und auf Erden:  theologische Bemerkungen zum Streben nach Gewinn,” Zeitschrift für Theologie und Kirche 94, no. 4 (Dezember 1997):  541 (532-552).