Salzburger Missale, Bd. 3 =Bayerische Staatsbibliothek Clm 15710, Bildnr. 127 |
Oscar Cullmann, Die Entstehung des Weinachtsfestes und die Herkunft des Weihnachtsbaumes (Suttgart: Quell Verlag, 1990 [1947]), 67-68. The great biblical scholar Oscar Cullmann was born in 1902, and first published this in 1947. So he would have been speaking of the first decade of the 20th century. I have tried to incorporate between the square brackets here some hints at the thesis set out on pp. 50-53, namely that the decorated Christmas tree is profoundly Christian in origin, i.e. that the latter two of its three stages of development were unmistakably Christian, and that only with the third (the second Christian), which was deeply indebted to the late medieval Paradise play staged in front of the church on Christmas Eve, do we begin to arrive at the Christmas tree we would all recognize today.
This thesis (set forth without the sort of scholarly apparatus one would expect from a scholar of Cullmann's stature) does appear to have withstood the test of time:
Cullmann is still cited and followed by Susan K. Roll in the great Theologische Realenzyklopädie, sv Weihnachten/Weihnachtsfest/Weinachtspredigt (vol. 35 (2003), p. 465, ll. 10-19).
Cf. now also David Bertaina, "Trees and decorations," in The Oxford handbook of Christmas, ed. Timothy Larson (2020), who references here Joe Perry, Christmas in Germany: a cultural history (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2010):
The origins of the practice of bringing a tree into the home has long stumped scholars. Some [beginning in 1858] have mistakenly claimed that the tree can be traced to Late Antique pagan tradition. . . . Readers have accepted these 'historicist fantasies' (Perry 2010: 55) for their accounts of the Christmas tree, and the myth continues to be repeated by contemporary media today. . . .The Christmas tree tradition most likely developed from a combination of medieval liturgical traditions and guild patronage to local communities, which over time were transformed into a private practice beginning in the sixteenth century. . . .
No comments:
Post a Comment