| Sassetta, Thomas Aquinas in Prayer (1423/5), Szépművészeti Múzeum, Budapest. |
eternity
present age
precious Body and Blood.
for ever and ever."
| Sassetta, Thomas Aquinas in Prayer (1423/5), Szépművészeti Múzeum, Budapest. |
![]() |
| Ronald Knox Society of North America |
| Fr. Hunwicke's Mutual Enrichment |
. . . we are mistaken to grub around in speculative might-have-beens. What is authoritative is not the speculative proto-history of the New Testament documents. Mgr Ronald Knox reminded us that I do not ask Blessed Q to bless the bed that I lie on, but the canon of Scripture that Holy Mother Church sets before us. Urmarkus and Protoluke are not our Scriptures; we owe no obsequium to the magisterium of the Jesus Seminar. Mark's longer ending, and the Pericope de Adultera are canonical even if they were not written by the authors of Mark and John. Ephesians, and the Pastoral Epistles, are canonical even if they are pseudonymous. And just as the apostolic kerygma coalesced authoritatively into the New Testament, so the apostolic ministry coalesced authoritatively into the form of ministry we have received from the same age. Speculations about the proto-history of that Threefold Ministry which is centered upon the monoepiscopacy do no harm; indeed Dom Gregory Dix demonstrated that Catholics can play these games with at least as great a show of erudition . . . and with distinctly more verve and wit . . . than Protestants and liberals. But, wherever they come from, such speculations are not the authoritative basis upon which the tradition may be messed around with. Those adaptations which each age calls for must develop organically from the normative tradition which Scripture, Fathers and the classical liberal traditions witness.
"God would not be God if there could be any altering the universality and logic and completeness of what is necessarily done here, if there could be any escaping this sequence of sin and destruction. It means eternal perdition to have God against us. But if we will what God does not will, we do have God against us, and therefore we hurry and run and stumble and fall [(läuft, rennt, stürzt und fällt)] into eternal perdition.Priest (in a low voice):Lord, You have granted us to offer these common prayers in unison and have promised that when two or three agree in Your name, You will grant their requests. Fulfill now, O Lord, the petitions of Your servants as may be of benefit to them, granting us in the present age the knowledge of Your truth, and in the age to come eternal life.
And he exclaims:For You, O God, are good and love mankind, and to You we offer glory, to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Spirit, now and forever and to the ages of ages.My own extremely literal and non-idiomatic little mere crib I supply here:
Thou [who (Ὁ)] art granting [(χαρισάμενος, ADP-NMS)] these common prayers in which we agree; Thou [who (ὁ)] art also promising [(ἐπαγγειλάμενος, AMP-NMS)] to grant [(παρέχειν)] the requests [of the] two and three [who] agree on your name; [the] same will also now be fulfilling [(πλήρωσον, FAP-NMS)] the requests of your servants unto/in order to/for the profitable, furnishing [(χορηγῶν, pAP-NMS)] us in the present aeon [with] the knowledge of thy truth and in the coming aeon life eternal granting [(χαριζόμενος, pAP-NMS)].As for the Latin translation that, according to Hatchett, misled Cranmer, see Anselm Strittmatter, "'Missa Grecorum' 'Missa Sancti Iohannis Chrisostomi': the oldest Latin version known of the Byzantine liturgies of St. Basil and St. John Chrysostom," Traditio 1 (1943): 92 l. 27-94 l. 2 (79-137), on file. According to Strittmatter, the manuscript in question was written (not necessarily translation was composed?) in the second half of the twelfth century. For "ducibus et tribubus" read "duobus et tribus"; on the mistranslation "ad conferendum", see 86 and 86n15; for "impresenti" Strittmatter offers "presenti":
Deus qui has communes et consonas orationes donasti, qui et ducibus et tribubus in nomine tuo conuenientibus peticiones prebere promisisti, ipse nunc postulationes seruorum tuorum ad conferendum comple, in presenti saeculo tuae ueritatis cognitionem largiendo et in futuro nobis uitam aeternam donaturus.
Quoniam obtimus et amator hominum existis, ac tibi gloriam dirigimus, patri et filio et spiritui sancto nunc et semper et in saecula saeculorum amen.
1544 English Litany:
1549: "Letany and Suffrages", The book of the common prayer, as reproduced in Cummings (2011), 45: "Almightie God, whiche hast geven us grace at this tyme | with one accorde to make our commune supplicacions | unto thee, and doest promise, that whan two or three | bee gathered in thy name, thou wylt graunt theyr | requestes: fulfill now, O lorde, the desires | and peticions of thy servauntes, as | maye bee moste expediente for them, | grauntyng us in this worlde know- | lege of thy trueth, and in | the worlde to come | lyfe everlasting. | Amen."
1662: Morning and Evening Prayer, Litany, Book of common prayer, as reproduced in Cummings (2011), 249, 257, 264: "Almighty God, who hast given us grace at this time with one accord to make our common supplications unto thee, and dost promise, that when two or three are gathered together in the Name, thou wilt grant their requests; Fulfill now, O Lord, the desires and petitions of thy servants, as may be most expedient for them; granting us in this world knowledge of thy truth, and in the world to come life everlasting. Amen."
1928: "Almighty God, who hast given us grace at this time with one accord to make our common supplications unto thee; and dost promise that when two or three are gathered together in the Name thou wilt grant their requests; Fulfill now, O Lord, the desires and petitions of thy servants, as may be most expedient for them; granting us in this world knowledge of thy truth, and in the world to come life everlasting. Amen."
1979 (above): As Hatchett (131) says, a return to what Mt 18:20 actually says when not conflated, as by Cranmer—following "a [no later than the late 12th century] Latin translation of the prayer" (however, Hatchett doesn't himself say which "Latin translation" he is speaking of—, with Mt 18:19: "thou wilt be in the midst of them".
c. 2012 (the Catholic Ordinariates, e.g. The customary of our Lady of Walsingham: Daily prayer for the Ordinariates, followed in 2021 by Divine worship: Daily office (Commonwealth and North American editions both)): a return to Cranmer and that "unfortunate" Latin "conflation" of Mt 18:20a with Mt 18:19b: "thou wilt grant their requests".